If Lydia Davis Wrote About Retirement and the Deficiencies of the 401(k) Plan
Tuesday, December 9th, 2008If I enjoy my work, I don’t have a problem with the idea of working into my eighties or even later. If I do not enjoy my work, I will not live to see the Social Security retirement age of 62.
I do not enjoy my work. I should quit, otherwise I will die. Also, my company has eliminated its pension plan, so there is no reward for not quitting.
There is a problem: most of the money I have saved is in my 401(k) retirement account, and I am not allowed to have that money until I have reached the age of 59 1/2. That’s my money, they say, but I cannot have it.
There is another problem: my 401(k) has much less money in it today than it did one year ago. So even if I could have my money that I’m not allowed to have, it would mean that I have less now than I did before or than I might when I am 59 1/2.
There is yet another problem: if I continue to do this work I do not enjoy until the age of 59 1/2 or even the age of 62, and if I do not die, there is no way to know whether my 401(k) will have enough money to support me.
There is one last problem: even if my 401(k) has enough value to support me when I’m 59 1/2, that money will have to last me for the rest of my life, and if I’ve made it to 59 1/2 working a job I do not enjoy, there’s no telling how long I might live.
If I quit my job, I cannot live. If I don’t quit my job, I will probably die by the time I reach retirement age. If I manage to live until retirement age, I may not have enough money to live because I will not know when I will die, and my savings will be finite.
This thought brings me to the essence of the problem: someday I will die, but I do not know when.

